Our Blog | here's what's on our mind!


Cause & Effect – Will marketers make Wanamaker right again with their undying reliance on last-click attribution?

by
Paul Otis
Nov 29, 2016

Everyone has heard John Wanamaker’s famous (and quite honestly tired) quote “Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is I don't know which half.” Many marketers and advertisers point to the progress we’ve made in ad tracking and now believe that the then prescient Wanamaker would be so happy in today’s “accountable” climate. But would he be?

It appears that even with big data and an array of tracking mechanisms, measurable media tools, and online and offline technology that many marketers, especially the local and regional ones, are just too busy to use the technology available to them. Worse yet, when measuring media cause and effect, they settle for the last click as the primary attribution.

As you probably know or can surmise, the last click refers to the model in which the last click is given 100% credit for a sale or a conversion. It tracks where the user last came from prior to clicking on a page, calling or filling out a form. But is this as accurate as we want to be? Mr. Wanamaker is likely turning in his grave.

MOB Media has always billed ourselves as an accountable ad agency. What that means to us is that any sustainable ad campaign must be optimizable, repeatable and trackable, and of course, effective. When clients tell us that they don't believe TV or radio or YouTube won't get them the traffic or leads they need, we immediately go to their attribution system. Guess what? The last click is the primary and oftentimes only means by which they are measuring success.

We’ve had clients tell us point blank that they know a particular media channel works, but then in reports to their CEOs and board members there’s a desolate spreadsheet for lead generation in that very same channel. I’ve even had clients tell me that they don’t pay attention to sourcing the dropdowns they created on their own website forms. If the last source was PPC, it's the reason for the form fill, whether or not the consumer dropped down and chose another medium. So why is this happening in today’s day and age?

Let’s see, whom to admonish first? Let’s start with the big one. The goliath. The $74.5 Billion Gorilla named Google. Every client, every marketer, almost everyone that has a website relies on Google Analytics (GA) for most, if not all, of their web analytics. Well, isn’t that nice! Like the fox protecting the henhouse, isn’t it? I mean, let’s face it, Google makes most of its money on search engine marketing (PPC). Isn’t it convenient that "Last Click Attribution" will most of the time come from the PPC media channel? Even Google itself tries to warn against choosing last click attribution unless “your paths to purchase are direct enough, that the default last-click approach may be the right choice”. When is the marketing world that simple? What about the cause and effect of branding, TV, radio, YouTube, print, out-of-home and so much more? The Last Click just means, that after Joe Consumer saw the required 3x frequency of my ads on TV and heard the radio commercial ample times he went online for a YouTube demonstration and then searched for my product on Google, found it in the search engine results page (SERP) and clicked on that ad. Yup, PPC was the reason Joe Consumer bought my product or visited my website. Sure it was.

The classic fallacy of correlation does not imply causation. Simply put, Google tracks the source of the traffic, not the cause of that traffic! Yet marketers knowingly use GA as their gold standard for tracking their media.

Another factor for this attribution marketing malaise is that the marketing directors and their people are too overwhelmed with data and exhaustive work to really try to sift through all that is available to them and so instead take the shortcuts mentioned above just to stay above water. Overworked and understaffed is often what we see with local and regional clients. But what makes them busier than ever when technology is supposed to make their jobs easier?

Well, I’ve written on one of those issues before – the silo mentality of hiring multiple agencies and services to handle their marketing. Without going over retread material, suffice it to say that most local and regional clients only need one ad agency (I would like to think MOB Media!) to holistically handle and be responsible for the entire advertising campaign. That way, the ad agency in question can be media agnostic as to what works, how it’s working and will utilize proper attribution models to highlight the benefits of other media channels that perhaps aren’t getting direct credit, but are affecting the overall increase in traffic, sales or leads.

So, giving 100% attribution to a PPC lead is, in my humble opinion, actually worse than not knowing where half of your ad expenditures have been wasted. Find a suitable attribution model that takes into account 3-4 sources and influencers. Better yet, find yourself a good ad agency and let them deal with it and report back to you and the board.

By the way, John Wanamaker is an interesting read. I encourage you to learn more about him. He was a pioneer in marketing especially on the retail level and is credited with first using a price tag. He also reformed the US Postal system and was president of the YMCA.

3290 comments

Leave a comment
  1. MOB Media Limo Fahr | Jun 24, 2019

    The content has been highlighted very nicely..Book Online Taxi In New York

  2. MOB Media Anthony | Jun 24, 2019
    Pandora Bracelet Charms
    Nike Air Max 98
    Christian Louboutin shoes
    Nike Running Shoes For Women
    Balenciaga Sneakers
    Air Max 2019
    Vans
    Nike Shoes
    Yeezy
    Nike Cortez Men
    Adidas Outlet UK
    Pandora Earrings
    Balenciaga Shoes
    Pandora Bracelet Charms
    Adidas Yeezy Sneakers
    Nike Sneakers
    Fila Sneakers
    Nike Outlet
    Nike
    Christian Louboutin Shoes Outlet
    Longchamp Outlet Online
    Nike Outlet Online
    Air Max 720
    Stan Smith Adidas
    Nike Clearance
    Nike Air Max
    New Shoes
    Valentino Shoes
    Timberland Shoes
    Adidas Shoes
    Nike Outlet Store
    Nike Sneakers For Women
    Adidas EQT Support Adv
    Adidas Ultra Boost
    NMD
    Ultra Boost
    Nike Shoes
    Jordan 11s
    Pandora Ring
    Asics Shoes
    Nike Running Shoes
    Air Max 270 Women
    Adidas Outlet UK
    Nike Factory Store
    Nike Outlet Store
    Nike 270 Air Max
    Stan Smith Adidas
    Fjallraven Kanken Backpack
    Adidas Superstar Women
    Adidas Sneakers
    Pandora Bracelet
    Yeezy 500 Blush
    Yeezy 550
    Adidas Shoes
    Nike Outlet Store Online Shopping
    Adidas NMD R1
    Puma Outlet
    Adidas Outlet
    Air Jordan Retro
    Adidas Trainers
    Yeezy Boost 350
    Asics Shoes
    Nike Shoes
    Nike Running Shoes For Men
    Asics Shoes
    Adidas Ultra Boost
    Red Bottom Shoes
    Nike Factory Store
    Nike Store UK
    Nike Factory Outlet Store Online
    Cheap Basketball Shoes
    Off White Nike
    Christian Louboutin Shoes
    Christian Louboutin
    Asics Outlet
    Nike Shoes
    Yeezy
    Yeezy 500
    Yeezy Shoes
    Red Bottoms
    Nike Air Max 98
    Yeezy Supply
    Adidas Store
    Pandora Canada
    Nike Men's Running Shoes
    Asics Running Shoes
    Nike Outlet
    Pandora Jewelry
    Off White Air Force 1
    Nike Store
    Nike Air Max 2019
    Nike Outlet Store Online Shopping
    Goyard Handbags
    Air Max 270 Men
    Yeezy Boost 350
    Nike Shoes
    Timberland Boots For Men
    Pandora Charms Outlet
    Nike Shoes
    Fjallraven
    Air Jordan Sneakers
    Nike Shoes
    Adidas Outlet
    Puma Outlet Store
    New Adidas
    Nike Air Max 270 Womens
    Golden Goose
    KD 11
    Adidas Shoes
    Pandora Ring
    Pandora Jewelry
    Pandora Charm
    Pandora Charms
    Fila Disruptor ii
    Michael Jordan Shoes
    Nike Clearance
    Shoes For Women
    Adidas Ultra Boost
    Pandora Outlet
    Nike Outlet Store
    Adidas Superstars
    Adidas UK
    Adidas Outlet
    Nike Clearance Store
    Louboutin Outlet
    Pandora Official Site
    Skechers Shoes
    Red Bottom Heels
    Adidas Ultra Boost Men
    Nike Shoes
    KD Shoes
    Hermes Belt
    Adidas NMD
    Yeezy
    Nike Cortez
    Nike Sneakers
    Asics
    Pandora Charms
    Goyard
    Pandora Jewelry Store
    Nike Outlet Online
    Red Bottom Shoes
    Adidas Superstar Shoes
    Christian Louboutin Shoes
    Adidas Yeezy
    Adidas Shoes
    Jordan Shoes
    Jordan 11
    Yeezy Boost
    NMD
    Adidas Yeezy
    NMD Adidas
    Nike Air Max 90
    Air Max
    Ferragamo
    Nike Factory Outlet
    Pandora Jewelry Official Site
    Pandora UK
    Nike Shoes
    Pandora Jewelry
    Asics
    Adidas Originals Superstar
    Adidas Outlet Online
    Lebron James Shoes
    Timberland Boots
    Kids Nike Shoes
    Timberland Outlet
    Nike Air Max 98
    Pandora Store
    Adidas NMD XR1
    Fitflops Sale Clearance
    Pandora Jewelry
    Air Max 95
    Red Bottom Shoes For Women
    Yeezy
    Nike Shoes 2019
    Nike Outlet Store
    Valentino Shoes Outlet
    Cheap Yeezy
    Pandora Necklace
    Nike 720
    Christian Louboutin Outlet
    NMD xr1
    Adidas Trainers Sale
    Nike UK
    Nike Air Max 95 Essential
    Nike Clearance Outlet UK
    Nike Air Max 97
    New Nike Trainers
    Louboutin
    Christian Louboutin Outlet
    Air Max 97
    New Nike Shoes 2019
    Adidas Outlet Online
    Adidas EQT Support
    Yeezy
    Pandora Jewelry Official Site
    Nike Outlet Store Online Shopping
    Adidas Sale
    Yeezy
    Nike Clearance
    Yeezys
    Moncler Website
    Nike Lebron 16
    Pandora Jewelry
    Nike Outlet Store
    Adidas Superstar
    Christian Louboutin Outlet
    Goyard Handbags
    Nike Air Max 270
    Pandora Outlet
    Ferragamo Belt
    Hermes Birkin Handbags
    Pandora Jewelry Outlet
    Nike Sneakers
    Nike Outlet Store Online
    Asics Running Shoes
    Valentino
    Fjallraven Kanken
    Pandora Jewelry
    Ferragamo Shoes
    Pandora Bracelets Clearance
    Adida
    Adidas Sneakers
    Timberland Shoes
    Timberland Shoes
    Pandora Charms
    Asics Shoes
    Pandora Jewelry
    Adidas
    Adidas NMD
    Nike Basketball Shoes
    Fila Shoes For Women
    Nike Factory
  3. MOB Media SEO expert | Jun 23, 2019
    Explore electronic resources for free, thousands of eBooks, accounting eBooks, business eBooks, Marketing eBooks, Accounting eBooks, Banking eBooks, Design eBooks, Customers eBooks, Travel and Tourism eBooks…  Al-Zaytoonah Elibrary
  4. MOB Media hannahc | Jun 23, 2019
    This is highly fantastic website, Keep up the most powerful perform here sheet music folder
  5. MOB Media james | Jun 23, 2019

    JKWATERCRAFTPARTS HAS BEEN SELLING QUALITY REPLACEMENT PARTS TO REBUILD YOUR WATERCRAFT, JETSKI, MARINE, BOAT, INBOARD AND OUTBOARD ENGINE FOR OVER A DECADE.

    Marine Piston Rebuild

  6. MOB Media hac | Jun 23, 2019
    I see the superlative contents on your blogs and I perfectly enjoy going through them. best live chat sites
  7. MOB Media hac | Jun 23, 2019
    Much thanks to you for another extraordinary article. Where else would anyone be able to get that sort of data in such a flawless method for composing? I have a presentation one week from now, and I am on the search for such data.  sex cam reviews
  8. MOB Media hac | Jun 23, 2019
    I have as of late begun a website, the data you give on this webpage has helped me extraordinarily. Much obliged for the greater part of your time and work.  sex cam sites
  9. MOB Media hac | Jun 23, 2019
    New site is solid. A debt of gratitude is in order for the considerable exertion.  mobile adult cams
  10. MOB Media hac | Jun 23, 2019
    Totally awesome posting! Loads of valuable data and motivation, both of which we all need!Relay welcome your work.  best mobile adult webcams
  11. MOB Media chalsea | Jun 23, 2019
    Phenomenal website you have here. You'll find me taking a gander at your stuff regularly. Spared!  sky everton condo
  12. MOB Media bethanne | Jun 22, 2019
    stussy sweatshirt
    cheap nba jerseys store
    adidas outlet
    bose
    nhl jerseys shop
    fjallraven kanken backpack
    cheap mlb jerseys
    converse pas cher
    nike store
    cheap baseball jerseys
    supreme
    nba basketball jerseys
    custom NHL jerseys
    adidas
    stan smith
    nike shoes
    soccer jerseys
    Balenciaga Shoes
    nike air max 97
    kd shoes
    north face vest
    ecco mens shoes
    Chrome Hearts
    nmd
    new balance
    discount nfl jerseys
    Off White Clothing
    puma shoes
    nike air max
    NHL jerseys
    air jordan xi
    wholesale nhl jerseys
    cheap NFL jerseys
    kate spade bags
    north face jacket
    vans old school
    adidas ultra boost
    nike air max 2019
    Adidas Off White
    nine west
    skechers
    salomon shoes
    zx flux
    NFL shop
    new nba jerseys
    timberland shoes
    jordan shoes
    discount mlb jerseys
    baseball jerseys
    Trajes Hugo Boss
    lebron 15
    new balance
    Swimsuits
    cheap nfl jerseys
    nine west outlet
    Ed Hardy Clothing
    wholesale nhl jerseys
    Calvin Klein Shoes
    adidas originals ultra boost
    Zapatillas Puma
    salomon running shoes
    Lacoste Outlet
    Converse All Star
    custom baseball jerseys
    Calvin Klein Jeans
    clarks sandals
    bague pandora
    puma suede
    adidas superstar
    adidas eqt support
    mizuno volleyball shoes
    mizuno
    air max
    Off White
    jordan shoes
    Cheap NBA Jerseys
    kate spade outlet
    bose speakers
    Adidas
    jordan 4
    Camisas Ralph Lauren
    Botas De Football Nike
    geox sneakers
    ecco
    jordan
    kate spade handbags
    Christian Louboutin
    new nfl jerseys
    supreme clothing
    geox shoes
    fjallraven kanken
    Armani Ropa
    cheap nhl jerseys
    Lacoste Outlet
    Versace Outlet
    converse shoes
    Zapatillas Vans
    nfl jersey outlet
    chaussure fila
    nba jerseys
    yeezy shoes
    yeezy shoes
    nike air max
    air max
    cheap soccer jerseys
    nhl jerseys store
    chaussure salomon
    nike basketball shoes
    levis jeans
    converse all star
    stussy outlet
    chaussure balenciaga
    mlb jerseys shop
    coach
    levis
    basketball shoes
    NBA store
    skechers outlet
    nmd
    cheap MLB jerseys
    Calvin Klein Hombre
    Balenciaga Shoes
    wholesale nfl jerseys
    Nike
    nike air max
    cheap nba jerseys
    Guess Vestidos
  13. MOB Media tony | Jun 22, 2019

    Hi I am so pleased I found your blog, 

    luchthavenvervoer antwerpen

  14. MOB Media Lucy | Jun 22, 2019
    I love your article and I will surely share this! keto essentials
  15. MOB Media ahmed | Jun 22, 2019
    A debt of gratitude is in order for the instructive and supportive post, clearly in your blog everything is great..Tuin aanleggen
  16. MOB Media SEO expert | Jun 22, 2019
    The best source for high quality Kratom Mitragyna Speciosa Powders, Extracts and CBD oil. Buy Red, Green and White strain Kratom powders and capsules. green hulu kapuas
  17. MOB Media hac | Jun 22, 2019
    The groups not reading your blogs are missing out a lot of caliber material. sliding barn doors
  18. MOB Media piermont grand price | Jun 22, 2019
    all of my kids enjoy the park and rides in Disney World, disney really knows how to please kids` piermont grand price
  19. MOB Media Buy Instagram Followers | Jun 22, 2019
    I’m not sure why but this web site is loading incredibly slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it a problem on my end? I’ll check back later and see if the problem still exists. Buy Instagram Followers
  20. MOB Media kamagra uk1 | Jun 21, 2019
    Great post…thanks for sharing…..If you want to overcome ED, then place your order online  with a reputed Pharmacy Kamagra UK1….Choose. Hard On Jelly Hard On jellies Buy Hard On jellies Hard On jellies 100mg Online Cheap Hard On Jelly Hard On Jelly Online Hard On jellies Online Hard On Jelly UK        
  21. MOB Media Kamagra UK1 | Jun 21, 2019
    Great post…thanks for sharing…..If you want to overcome ED, then place your order online  with a reputed Pharmacy Kamagra UK1….Choose. Hard On Jelly Hard On jellies Buy Hard On jellies Hard On jellies 100mg Online Cheap Hard On Jelly Hard On Jelly Online Hard On jellies Online Hard On Jelly UK        
  22. MOB Media bilal khan | Jun 21, 2019
    It's remarkably a befuddling and key piece of data. I'm in staggering spirits that you in a general sense offered this astounding data to usStripster huren
  23. MOB Media school uniforms kids | Jun 21, 2019
    I got what you  intend,bookmarked , very nice    internet site . school uniforms kids
  24. MOB Media desatascar lavabo | Jun 21, 2019
    I like this  site  very much, Its a  rattling nice place   to read and get  info  . desatascar lavabo
  25. MOB Media ahmed | Jun 20, 2019
    I am impressed by the data that you have on this blog. It demonstrates how well you comprehend this subject.Warmtepomp
  26. MOB Media hac | Jun 20, 2019
    Hey eager stuff precise substance your response on Quad biking safari
  27. MOB Media bilal khan | Jun 20, 2019
    It's remarkably a befuddling and key piece of data. I'm in staggering spirits that you in a general sense offered this astounding data to usWarmtepompen
  28. MOB Media by Mailbanger | Jun 20, 2019
    The good news is that there is a solution – wildcard certificates. You can obtain SSL on as many subdomains as you want. by Mailbanger
  29. MOB Media learn more | Jun 20, 2019
    *Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing. learn more
  30. MOB Media dadu online | Jun 20, 2019
    Certainly I like your web-site, however you have to take a look at the spelling on quite a few of your posts. Several of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very troublesome to inform you. However I’ll definitely come back again! dadu online
  31. MOB Media pop up canopy | Jun 20, 2019
    I just wanted to tell you how much my partner and i appreciate anything you’ve discussed to help improve the lives of men and women in this subject matter. Through your current articles, I have gone through just a newcomer to a professional in the area. It’s truly a gratitude to your good work.  pop up canopy
  32. MOB Media Roger M. Lewis | Jun 19, 2019
    Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know.dentures washington dc
  33. MOB Media Roger M. Lewis | Jun 19, 2019
    including reasonable comments here...dentist washington dc
  34. MOB Media Remington | Jun 19, 2019

    You really are clever I was amazed by the contents you had posted.

    professional tax marketing

  35. MOB Media harlene | Jun 19, 2019
    washington capitals
    red sox
    lonzo ball stats
    earl thomas
    tony parker
    antonio brown
    providence bruins
    tom brady
    mets
    texans
    didi gregorius
    san francisco 49ers
    detroit lions
    lamar jackson
    demar derozan
    sj sharks
    cavs
    alex smith
    sixers
    raptors
    kyrie irving
    predators hockey
    mark teixeira
    yankees jersey
    colin kaepernick
    pk subban
    edmonton oilers
    st louis cardinals
    cleveland indians
    adam duvall
    new england patriots
    clayton kershaw
    carolina panthers
    kemba walker
    minnesota wild
    houston texans
    milwaukee brewers
    jayson tatum
    avery bradley
    oregon ducks
    kobe bryant jersey
    derek jeter
    todd frazier
    shin soo choo
    julian edelman
    florida marlins
    suns
    winnipeg jets
    alex ovechkin
    packers
    chris paul
    detroit pistons
    deandre hopkins
    devils
    penguins hockey
    michael moore
    kevin hayes
    victor oladipo
    san antonio spurs
    reuben foster
    arizona cardinals
    zach lavine
    colt mccoy
    mn vikings
    new york rangers
    philip rivers
    lesean mccoy
    los angeles chargers
    tb lightning
    lebron james jersey
    sabres
    colorado avalanche
    pistons
    cardnials
    stefon diggs
    cheap jerseys
    henrik lundqvist
    los angeles lakers
    henrik zetterberg
    mlb com
    charlie culberson
    minnesota vikings
    zach randolph
    blackhawks
    bengals
    kareem hunt
    josh gordon
    red sox jersey
    bucs
    aaron donald
    zach parise
    stephen curry
    melvin gordon
    cubs schedule
    new york jets
    spurs
    crosby
    mark stone
    ben bishop
    la chargers
    washington caps
    ny mets
    philadelphia phillies
    lonzo ball
    ny yankees
    matt martin
    new york yankees
    golden state warriors
    warriors
    carolina hurricanes
    baker mayfield
    denver broncos
    christian villanueva
    chargers
    matt ryan
    canadiens
    charlie coyle
    lewis brinson
    eagles
    jj redick
    76ers
    indiana pacers
    arizona diamondbacks
    jordy nelson
    clippers
    texas rangers
    drew doughty
    cleveland browns
    hornet
    new york giants
    nfl
    boston bruins
    panthers
    jared goff
    mlb
    johnny gaudreau
    ohio state football
    bucks
    jj watt
    capitals
    derrick henry
    jerseys
    damian lillard
    ny islanders
    braves
    toronto maple leafs
    baltimore orioles
    orlando magic
    sf giants schedule
    angels baseball
  36. MOB Media bilal khan | Jun 19, 2019
    It's outstandingly a bewildering and key bit of information. I'm in stunning spirits that you in a general sense offered this astonishing information to usOpleiding kapper
  37. MOB Media ahmed | Jun 19, 2019
    This is such an incredible asset, that you are giving and you give it away for nothing.Airco prijs
  38. MOB Media William | Jun 19, 2019
    the secret to getting a date with a hot girl Thanks for sharing this blog. It is very useful for everyone. Keep on rocking!
  39. MOB Media homepage | Jun 19, 2019
    Regards  for this post, I am a big fan  of this website   would like to  go along updated. homepage
  40. MOB Media Massage Therapy | Jun 19, 2019
    Spot on with this write-up, I truly assume this website wants much more consideration.  probably be again to read much more, thanks for that info. Massage Therapy
  41. MOB Media Leanport | Jun 19, 2019
    This blog is so informative and articulated very well. Search Engine Marketing Agency Berlin
  42. MOB Media rv altitude | Jun 19, 2019
    Perfect work  you have done, this  site is really cool with good   information. rv altitude
  43. MOB Media 除毛,真空除毛 | Jun 19, 2019
    Advantageously, typically the submit is really the very best about this laudable theme. To be sure with all your a conclusion and will thirstily await the following revisions. Really stating cheers won’t only end up being suitable, to your good readability within your creating. I may at once seize a person’s rss to sleep in abreast of virtually any upgrades. Fine job and much success within your organization business! 除毛,真空除毛
  44. MOB Media ahmed | Jun 19, 2019
    Incredibly intriguing information, worth recommending. In any case, I recommend thisAirco
  45. MOB Media susank | Jun 19, 2019
    This post truly magnificent. Keep it up the best perform you here alcohol and drug services auckland
  46. MOB Media max | Jun 18, 2019

    A debt of gratitude is in order for the post. I'll positively rebound. 

    먹튀사이트

  47. MOB Media Junny | Jun 17, 2019
    I like the helpful info you supply in your articles. I will bookmark your weblog and test once more right here frequently. I am relatively sure I will learn many new stuff right right here! Best of luck for the next! gold ira reviews
  48. MOB Media Elena | Jun 17, 2019
    Thanks a bunch for the informative blog. I’ve been digging around for info, but there is so much out there. Keep up the great information. I will be coming back over here in a few days to see if there is updated posts. graco 4 in 1 car seat
  49. MOB Media Baron | Jun 17, 2019
    Awesome, you save my time finding good resource for my project! keto supplements
  50. MOB Media ahmed | Jun 17, 2019
    Extraordinary Information sharing .. I am extremely glad to peruse this article .. a debt of gratitude is in order for giving us experience info.Fantastic pleasant. I value this post.Zonnepanelen
    MOB Media

    Leave a comment