Our Blog | here's what's on our mind!


Cause & Effect – Will marketers make Wanamaker right again with their undying reliance on last-click attribution?

by
Paul Otis
Nov 29, 2016

Everyone has heard John Wanamaker’s famous (and quite honestly tired) quote “Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is I don't know which half.” Many marketers and advertisers point to the progress we’ve made in ad tracking and now believe that the then prescient Wanamaker would be so happy in today’s “accountable” climate. But would he be?

It appears that even with big data and an array of tracking mechanisms, measurable media tools, and online and offline technology that many marketers, especially the local and regional ones, are just too busy to use the technology available to them. Worse yet, when measuring media cause and effect, they settle for the last click as the primary attribution.

As you probably know or can surmise, the last click refers to the model in which the last click is given 100% credit for a sale or a conversion. It tracks where the user last came from prior to clicking on a page, calling or filling out a form. But is this as accurate as we want to be? Mr. Wanamaker is likely turning in his grave.

MOB Media has always billed ourselves as an accountable ad agency. What that means to us is that any sustainable ad campaign must be optimizable, repeatable and trackable, and of course, effective. When clients tell us that they don't believe TV or radio or YouTube won't get them the traffic or leads they need, we immediately go to their attribution system. Guess what? The last click is the primary and oftentimes only means by which they are measuring success.

We’ve had clients tell us point blank that they know a particular media channel works, but then in reports to their CEOs and board members there’s a desolate spreadsheet for lead generation in that very same channel. I’ve even had clients tell me that they don’t pay attention to sourcing the dropdowns they created on their own website forms. If the last source was PPC, it's the reason for the form fill, whether or not the consumer dropped down and chose another medium. So why is this happening in today’s day and age?

Let’s see, whom to admonish first? Let’s start with the big one. The goliath. The $74.5 Billion Gorilla named Google. Every client, every marketer, almost everyone that has a website relies on Google Analytics (GA) for most, if not all, of their web analytics. Well, isn’t that nice! Like the fox protecting the henhouse, isn’t it? I mean, let’s face it, Google makes most of its money on search engine marketing (PPC). Isn’t it convenient that "Last Click Attribution" will most of the time come from the PPC media channel? Even Google itself tries to warn against choosing last click attribution unless “your paths to purchase are direct enough, that the default last-click approach may be the right choice”. When is the marketing world that simple? What about the cause and effect of branding, TV, radio, YouTube, print, out-of-home and so much more? The Last Click just means, that after Joe Consumer saw the required 3x frequency of my ads on TV and heard the radio commercial ample times he went online for a YouTube demonstration and then searched for my product on Google, found it in the search engine results page (SERP) and clicked on that ad. Yup, PPC was the reason Joe Consumer bought my product or visited my website. Sure it was.

The classic fallacy of correlation does not imply causation. Simply put, Google tracks the source of the traffic, not the cause of that traffic! Yet marketers knowingly use GA as their gold standard for tracking their media.

Another factor for this attribution marketing malaise is that the marketing directors and their people are too overwhelmed with data and exhaustive work to really try to sift through all that is available to them and so instead take the shortcuts mentioned above just to stay above water. Overworked and understaffed is often what we see with local and regional clients. But what makes them busier than ever when technology is supposed to make their jobs easier?

Well, I’ve written on one of those issues before – the silo mentality of hiring multiple agencies and services to handle their marketing. Without going over retread material, suffice it to say that most local and regional clients only need one ad agency (I would like to think MOB Media!) to holistically handle and be responsible for the entire advertising campaign. That way, the ad agency in question can be media agnostic as to what works, how it’s working and will utilize proper attribution models to highlight the benefits of other media channels that perhaps aren’t getting direct credit, but are affecting the overall increase in traffic, sales or leads.

So, giving 100% attribution to a PPC lead is, in my humble opinion, actually worse than not knowing where half of your ad expenditures have been wasted. Find a suitable attribution model that takes into account 3-4 sources and influencers. Better yet, find yourself a good ad agency and let them deal with it and report back to you and the board.

By the way, John Wanamaker is an interesting read. I encourage you to learn more about him. He was a pioneer in marketing especially on the retail level and is credited with first using a price tag. He also reformed the US Postal system and was president of the YMCA.

2351 comments

Leave a comment
  1. MOB Media digitinc | Dec 14, 2018
    You have shared a informative and interesting blog post. Thank you for sharing. Bridging Loan
  2. MOB Media Robinjack | Dec 14, 2018
    Hi there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it is really informative. I’m going to watch out for brussels. I’ll appreciate if you continue this in future. Many people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers! https://parallelprofitsreview.ning.com/
  3. MOB Media anamika | Dec 13, 2018
  4. MOB Media e | Dec 13, 2018
    Cerita pendek adalah cerita yang membatasi diri dalam membahas salah satu unsur fiksi dalam aspeknya yang terkecil. Kependekan sebuah cerita pendek bukan karena bentuknya yang jauh lebih pendek dari novel, tetapi karena aspek masalahnya yang sangat dibatasi. Saya catat dan simpan berbagai panduan cara menulis buku cerita anak tersebut. Salah satu panduan menulis buku cerita pendek untuk anak adalah. cara menulis buku blog ini. Pengertian menulis dalam arti sederhana dapat diartikan sama dengan mengarang yaitu mencorat coret dengan alat tulis pada sebuah lembaran kertas atau sejenisnya. Dalam kegiatan ini, menulis belum tentu menghasilkan tulisan atau karangan yang teratur dan mengandung sebuah satu kesatuan ide atau tujuan yang hendak dicapai.Siapa bilang berbisnis harus dimulai dengan modal besar. Sebenarnya buat kamu yang pengin banget mulai bisnis, coba deh mulai dari bisnis kecil-kecilan dulu. Contoh bisnis modal kecil untung besar yang bisa anda manfaatkan. contoh bisnis modal kecil untung besar di blog. Bagaimana contoh bisnis modal kecil untung besar? Salah satu contohnya, bisnis dengan modal 1 juta aja. Selain gak sulit buat kamu kumpulkan modal, risikonya juga cukup kecil. Modal 1 juta gak terlalu besar jadi risikonya juga gak terlalu besar. Namun, DuitPintar udah merangkumkan beberapa ide bisnis menarik yang tentunya diharapkan berhasil.Apakah Anda adalah salah satu karyawan tetap di sebuah perusahaan dan ingin memiliki penghasilan lebih? Usaha sampingan merupakan jalan keluarnya. Usaha sampingan merupakan pilihan bebas untuk karyawan dan perusahaan tidak melarangnya, selama tidak bertentangan dengan peraturan atau bisnis dari perusahaan. cara usaha kecil sampingan menguntungkan . Kalau kita bicara usaha modal kecil berarti kita memang tetap punya modal yang cukup untuk memulai bisnis tersebut. Walaupun jumlahnya terbatas kita tetap harus mengeluarkan uang. Selain itu kita juga harus punya modal non-materil seperti pengetahuan tentang bisnis yang akan dijalankan (ini bisa dipelajari), modal kemauan & usaha yang keras.Aku telah membuatkan sebuah kata kata romantis tentang cinta yang aku ringkas dan dirangkum kedalam sebuah kata kata cinta romantis. ungkapan kata kata cinta romantis sejati di blog. Kata Kata Bijak – Mengambil hikmah dan pelajaran di setiap kata kata mutiara bijak yang pernah diucapkan oleh orang-orang hebat yang pernah terlahir ke dunia akan memberikan kekuatan motivasi kepada kita.Biar makin asyik, kayaknya seru juga nih ngebayangin siapa kira-kira yang cocok berperan di novel ini jika suatu saat novel ini diangkat jadi drama atau film. Baca saja di Novel Cinta Arafah di blog. Sebuah novel selalu menyajikan kata kata cinta yang selalu dikenang. Itulah sebabnya mengapa novel menjadi salah satu media yang banyak disukai orang. Kata kata cinta itu kemudian berpadu dengan indahnya alur cerita dan membuat kisah cinta yang disajikan dalam novel semakin meyentuh. Anda pun juga turut hanyut dalam alur cerita karena membaca deretan kata kata cinta.Novel cinta dan romantis karya Pidi Baiq ini memang bisa bikin orang yang baca baper dan senyum-senyum sendiri. Dan karakter wanitanya bernama Milea, kisah romantis saat Dilan deketin Milea bikin banyak orang mendambakan kisah cinta seperti yang ada di novel. Novel Cinta Dan Rahasia di blog. Melalui untaian kata kata cinta tersebut, pembaca bisa semakin mengerti arti cinta. Anda dapat membayangkan perasaan si tokoh dalam novel melalui kata kata cinta. Atau mungkin kisah cinta dalam novel tersebut serupa dengan kisah cinta Anda. Ladi ngidam sambel pecel? Nggak perlu lagi nunggu tukang pecel lewat depan rumah, kamu bisa kok buat sendiri pecel favorit kamu dengan Sambal Pecel. jual sambal pecel. dan baca juga klik disini dalam resep kali ini kita akan memanfaatkan kacang tanah untuk diolah menjadi sambel pecel, berikut adalah resepnya. Sambal pecel merupakan bumbu makanan yang dibuat dari kacang tanah, cabai, gula merah (atau gula putih), daun jeruk nipis (atau buahnya), buah asam.
  5. MOB Media hac | Dec 13, 2018
    Rattling work man, ready your heads last you did it. clean eating
  6. MOB Media Robinjack | Dec 13, 2018
    Appreciably, this amazing blog is usually the nicest using this visible question. Naturally i harmonise with all your a conclusion but will thirstily wait for your entire one way up-dates. Stating thanks much will not only possibly be necessary, for ones dramatic quality with your coming up with. I could easily pick up your main rss to stay in advised from a improvements. Excellent hard work and far accomplishment of your home business deals!  Please justify my personal substandard British free of cost . absolutely not items to start with language. UFABET
  7. MOB Media Joel | Dec 12, 2018
    Your blog and every other content is so entertaining and useful It makes me come back again.  ben hogan clubs
  8. MOB Media digitinc | Dec 12, 2018
    I appreciate your consideration guidance. I have bookmark your site for future updates.  letter to prime minister 
  9. MOB Media Ashley Martin | Dec 12, 2018
    great i like it https://ashleymartin03.blogspot.com/
  10. MOB Media asd | Dec 11, 2018
    Excellent browse, I simply passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. And hubby actually bought me lunch as a result of I stumbled on it for him smile thus well then , sick rephrase that: thanks for lunch! https://eriecdp.org/his-secret-obsession-review
  11. MOB Media asd | Dec 11, 2018
    Hi there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it’s truly informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I will be grateful if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers! Judi Online
  12. MOB Media elizabethm | Dec 10, 2018
    Thanks for your post I adored the ideas and things right here male extra male enhancement
  13. MOB Media Robinjack | Dec 10, 2018
    Hi my friend! I wish to say that this article is awesome, nice written and include approximately all significant infos. I’d like to see extra posts like this. https://parallel-profits-review.blogspot.com/
  14. MOB Media Cold Stone Franchise | Dec 10, 2018
    Thanks  for another great post. Where else may just anybody get that kind of information in such an ideal way of writing? I have a presentation subsequent week, and I am on the search for such info. Cold Stone Franchise
  15. MOB Media asd | Dec 09, 2018
    Hello, I found your blog in a very new directory of blogs. I don’t discover how your website came up, should have been a typo. Your website looks good, use a nice day. leovegas
  16. MOB Media ASD | Dec 08, 2018
    I  really   delighted  to find this website   on bing, just what I was  searching  for : D also    saved to fav. casumo
  17. MOB Media Robinjack | Dec 08, 2018
    A debt of gratitude is in order for posting this data. I simply need to tell you that I simply look at your site and I discover it exceptionally fascinating and enlightening. I can hardly wait to peruse loads of your posts.  Wordpress bloggen
  18. MOB Media asd | Dec 07, 2018
    After examine a couple of of the weblog posts in your website now, and I truly like your manner of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and might be checking back soon. Pls take a look at my website as effectively and let me know what you think. casino games
  19. MOB Media Jennifer Brown | Dec 07, 2018
    Really this article is very useful and informative for everyone. And I hope you'll share more ideas and useful article with us. economics assignment help
  20. MOB Media asd | Dec 06, 2018
    our grandmother is a baby boomber and she is also a survivor of the holocaust. i’m so happy that she is still in good health till this day“ 18Bet
  21. MOB Media asd | Dec 05, 2018
    Great blog! Do you have any helpful hints for aspiring writers? I’m hoping to start my own blog soon but I’m a little lost on everything. Would you recommend starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so many options out there that I’m totally overwhelmed .. Any ideas? Appreciate it! bonus
  22. MOB Media asd | Dec 05, 2018
    Ha ha… I was just browsing around and took a glimpse at these responses. I can’t believe there’s still this much attention. Thanks for posting about this. executive search firm
  23. MOB Media targeted traffic | Dec 04, 2018
    Positive site. I appreciate the information and advice you have shared.  targeted traffic 
  24. MOB Media Ken | Dec 04, 2018
    Where to buy testofuel Thanks for the share, this is actually very informative post. Keep sharing and looking forward to your great work.. 
  25. MOB Media Robinjack | Dec 04, 2018
    nice one for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, could you mind updating your website with more info? as it is extremely useful for me. casino girlz
  26. MOB Media digitinc | Dec 03, 2018
    You provide very useful data. I appreciate your guidance.  csc vle registration
  27. MOB Media digitinc | Dec 03, 2018
    You provide very useful data. I appreciate your guidance.  marketing online Barcelona
  28. MOB Media asd | Dec 03, 2018
    Certainly completely with your conclusions and think that you’ve made some excellent points. Also, I like design of your respective site plus the easier navigation. I’ve bookmarked your website and may return often! dublinbet
  29. MOB Media asd | Dec 02, 2018
    The following time I read a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I truly thought youd have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about one thing that you may fix should you werent too busy looking for attention. lucky31
  30. MOB Media digitinc | Dec 02, 2018
    I am appreciative of your article and look forward to your continuing to work on our account. Thank you for sharing. Hosting
  31. MOB Media sad | Dec 02, 2018
    Lawyers… [...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]… Best herbs for diabetes
  32. MOB Media Robinjack | Dec 01, 2018
    This was a truly awesome challenge and ideally I can go to the following one. It was alot of fun and I truly had a ball..  https://eriecdp.org/parallel-profits-review
  33. MOB Media Herbert | Dec 01, 2018
    This is great blog. Testofuel review I’ll definitely be back to read more great stuff.
  34. MOB Media asd | Nov 30, 2018
    I like this  web site so much,  saved to my bookmarks . santan village mattress
  35. MOB Media asd | Nov 30, 2018
    Hiya! I simply wish to give an enormous thumbs up for the great data you will have right here on this post. I can be coming back to your blog for extra soon. Park Meadows mattress
  36. MOB Media asd | Nov 30, 2018
    This is so good to see. We have do more things like this for other families. They are protecting us and we need to support them in this way. Mattress Store Cherry Creek
  37. MOB Media asd | Nov 30, 2018
    Hiya! I simply wish to give an enormous thumbs up for the great data you will have right here on this post. I can be coming back to your blog for extra soon. Park Meadows mattress
  38. MOB Media Barry | Nov 30, 2018
    Thanks for being so specific. I love your blog very much and I would like to visit here again for more updates. best weight loss supplements for women
  39. MOB Media asd | Nov 30, 2018
    The data you have posted is extremely helpful. The destinations you have alluded was great. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing...  tradacasino
  40. MOB Media cherrym | Nov 29, 2018
    Fantastic blog content thanks for the special information prime male
  41. MOB Media asd | Nov 29, 2018
    It can be tough to write about this topic. I think you did an excellent job though! Thanks for this! guts casino
  42. MOB Media Robinjack | Nov 28, 2018
    Internal direct, training, contentment, honour, forbearance plus sentence. Usually a percentage of problems that Tang Soo Write, the actual Mandarin chinese martial art related to self-defense, can educate we additionally instilling in you the strength not just in defend your business women and men capability related with spotting hazard joins to refrain from giving confrontation completely. betclic
  43. MOB Media bttyzam | Nov 27, 2018
    This is special precious information. I have really contented your blog site chicken nesting boxes
  44. MOB Media Robinjack | Nov 27, 2018
    My partner and i many thanks for wp style, where you down load it through? Many thanks beforehand! norgesspill
  45. MOB Media asd | Nov 26, 2018
    Spot lets start on this write-up, I honestly think this website needs much more consideration. I’ll oftimes be once more you just read a lot more, thank you for that info. casino news
  46. MOB Media Linda | Nov 25, 2018
    Excellent beat ! I would like to follow your site at the same time I will commend it to my friends!  ben hogan ptx irons
  47. MOB Media Robinjack | Nov 25, 2018
    Thanks for the post I actually learned something from it. Very good content on this site Always looking forward to new post. 32red
  48. MOB Media Robinjack | Nov 25, 2018
    Thank you for sharing excellent informations. Your site is very cool. I am impressed by the details that you’ve on this blog. It reveals how nicely you understand this subject. Bookmarked this website page, will come back for extra articles. You, my pal, ROCK! I found just the info I already searched all over the place and simply couldn’t come across. What a great web-site. 32 red
  49. MOB Media lindanm | Nov 24, 2018
    Thanks for improving this wonderful things. I really loved your topic here eye conditions and ulcerative colitis
  50. MOB Media mini | Nov 24, 2018
    Hello! I just wish to give an enormous thumbs up for the nice info you've got right here on this post. I will probably be coming back to your weblog for more soonGoogle Digital Unlocked final Exam Answers| Free Free Free

    Google Web Designers Basics Free

    Check Instagram Profile Pictures in Full Size

    MOB Media

    Leave a comment